24th March 2016
Winston Churchill declared that, “We shall fight on the beaches” – not ‘must’ or ‘will’ – but ‘shall’.
‘Shall’, ‘must’ and ‘will’ are all modal verbs (verbs used to express an obligation). In a commercial contract setting, you want to be sure that the strength of obligation agreed by the parties is reflected in the agreement.
Traditionally, conventions dictate that:
- ‘Will’ when used in the first person, conveys an obligation, whereas ‘shall’ merely a future intention.
- Conversely, when used in the second or third person, ‘will’ conveys a future obligation, whilst ‘shall’ imports compulsion and obligation.
Churchill’s dicta (“We shall fight on the beaches”) is a helpful way to remember this.
But inconsistent drafting means that one cannot rely on the traditional interpretation; terms needs to be read in the context of the overall agreement applying the usual (and common sense) principles:
- what is the natural and reasonable meaning of the clause?
- what did the parties intend?
- what makes (commercial) sense?
What about ‘must’? Interestingly, English legislation avoids the use of ‘will’ or ‘shall’ in favour of ‘must’. ‘Must’ always suggests an absolute obligation.
Needless to say, ‘may’ suggests discretion (‘we may fight on the beaches’ conjures up quite a different image). The same applies to the combination of ‘shall and may’.
So, which modal verb to use? In reality, it’s unlikely to make a significant difference to your contract, provided that the intended consequence is clear. But to avoid finding yourself in the minority of cases in which your agreement is subject to close scrutiny, ‘must’ provides the safest, most definitive drafting route to capturing your intended absolute obligation.
Churchill’s finer oratorical moments, however, are probably best left alone (together with Georges Clemenceau’s June 1918 speech, in which he went with ‘will’ (“I will fight in Paris”).
If you need advice on anything in this article
SPEAK TO A MEMBER OF OUR COMMERCIAL TEAM
Arrange a call
HOW CAN WE HELP?
To get in touch with one of our legal experts please fill in your details.
Enjoy That? You Might Like These:
events
28 February -
We are delighted to host a virtual webinar being held on Wednesday 20 March between 10am and 11am giving an update on the latest in procurement law. Read More
articles
20 February -
Can a landlord remove an abandoned vehicle from their property? In this article, we look at the potential pitfalls of vehicle abandonment and give practical guidance to landlords if a... Read More
articles
13 February -
In principle, yes. When someone publishes untrue material online that adversely affects another person’s reputation, they could be found liable for defamation. The term defamation covers libel and slander. In... Read More
Arrange a call
How can we help?
To get in touch with one of our legal experts please fill in your details.
© Blake Morgan 2024. All Rights reserved.
Blake Morgan LLP (registered number OC392078) is a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales with its registered office at New Kings Court, Tollgate, Chandler's Ford, Eastleigh, Hampshire, SO53 3LG. It is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA number 613716). A full list of its members is available at all of its offices. The term 'partner' is used to mean a member of the firm or employee who is a lawyer with equivalent standing and qualifications.
Its VAT registration number is GB 189 077069.